
Retention money is the percentage of each certificate that the client holds back until the works' defects liability period has passed. On a single job it looks like small change, but added up across all your jobs over a couple of years, it can be a significant sum that your company has earned and not yet been paid. And what isn't tracked often isn't claimed. This article explains what it is, what the regulations say for public works, what is worth agreeing in private contracts and how to keep count.
What is retention money
It is an amount that the client deducts from the payment of each certificate, or from the total for the works, to protect itself against defects that may appear after handover. If defects appear during the defects liability period and the contractor does not repair them, the client can use that money to have them repaired. If none appear, the money is returned.
It should be distinguished from other items it is often confused with:
- The final performance bond on public works, which is provided when the contract is awarded and can be lodged in cash, as a bank guarantee or as a surety insurance policy, or through retention from the price if the tender specifications provide for it.
- Tax withholding (IRPF, Spanish personal income tax) on the invoices of some professionals, which has nothing to do with the guarantee on the works.
- Penalties for delay or other breaches, which are not returned.
What the Public Sector Contracts Act says
In contracts with public authorities, the guarantee is regulated by Ley 9/2017, de Contratos del Sector Público (Spain's Public Sector Contracts Act):
- Amount: article 107.1 sets a final guarantee of 5% of the final tender price, excluding VAT. In special cases, the specifications may require an additional guarantee of up to another 5% (article 107.2). In works contracts, the successful bidder cannot be exempted from providing it.
- Form: article 108.1 allows cash or government debt securities, a bank guarantee and surety insurance. Article 108.2 adds that, where the specifications provide for it, in works contracts the final guarantee may be provided through retention from the price, in the form and under the conditions set by the specifications themselves.
- What it covers: under article 110, among other things, penalties, proper performance and, in works, the absence of faults or defects during the defects liability period.
- Defects liability period: article 243.3 says it is set by the specifications according to the nature and complexity of the works and cannot be less than one year, except in special cases. In the fifteen days before it ends, the site engineer or architect in charge writes a report on the condition of the works; if it is favourable, the guarantee is returned or cancelled and the final settlement is made.
- Return: article 111 establishes that, once the final settlement has been approved and the defects liability period has passed without any liabilities arising, the guarantee is returned. The decision to return it must be adopted and notified within two months of the end of the defects liability period; if it is delayed through the fault of the authority, it must also pay statutory interest for the delay.
There are further details (partial acceptances, assignment of the contract, time limits when acceptance does not take place for reasons beyond the contractor's control) that depend on the case. Before making a claim, read the specifications of your contract and the articles cited in the consolidated text on the BOE (Spain's Official State Gazette).
And in private works
Between individuals or private companies there is no general rule setting the percentage or the period for retention: it is whatever the contract says. That is why the contract should make clear, as a minimum:
- The percentage withheld and on what basis (with or without VAT).
- Whether it is withheld on each certificate or only at the end.
- The defects liability period and when it starts (normally, from acceptance).
- How it is returned: automatically at the end of the period or after an inspection.
- Whether it can be replaced by a bank guarantee or a surety insurance policy.
The same applies when you are the one withholding from your subcontractors: what you agree with the client should be reasonably reflected in what you agree with them.
How to show it on certificates and invoices
The clearest way of working is for each certificate to show three figures: the value of the works certified, the retention for that period and the net amount payable. And the running total of retentions on the job should always be in view.
Bear in mind that the treatment on the invoice (whether or not the retention reduces the taxable base, when VAT falls due on the part withheld) has tax consequences. Check with your adviser and always apply the same approach on every job.
Common mistakes
- Not recording the acceptance date. Without it you don't know when the defects liability period expires, and without an expiry date there is no reminder.
- Treating the retention as just another outstanding item from the client. Mixed in with unpaid invoices, it is easy to lose sight of the fact that it is a payment with a due date.
- Not asking for the report or certificate at the end of the period. In public works, the site engineer or architect's report is what opens the way to the return; in private works, a joint inspection avoids disputes.
- Not replenishing the guarantee. In public works, if penalties are enforced against the guarantee, the contractor has to replenish it within fifteen days (article 109.2 of Ley 9/2017).
- Forgetting retentions on subcontractors. They are a debt you owe, with a due date.
A simple checklist for keeping track
- One record per job with client, percentage, base, accumulated amount withheld, acceptance date and end-of-guarantee date.
- An alert one month before expiry so you can inspect the works and prepare the request for return.
- A quarterly review of all outstanding retentions, kept separate from overdue invoices.
- The same record for the retentions you make on your subcontractors.
What Gestrab gives you to keep it all clear
To keep control of a retention you need to know exactly what has been certified and what has been invoiced on each job. In Gestrab, each job distinguishes, item by item, the quantity planned, completed, certified and invoiced, and certificates are invoiced on a cumulative basis, so the base on which the retention is calculated is always in view. You can find it under certificates and cumulative invoicing.
If you use the optional integrated accounting, issued invoices and payments are posted automatically and you have each client's statements in the same program. You can see how it all fits together in Gestrab's features.


